PODCAST | Matthew Karlsson On Custardgate, Conflict And His Big Brother Australia 2026 Eviction – Matthew Karlsson became the fourth housemate evicted from Big Brother Australia 2026 after a turbulent captaincy, repeated house meetings and some of the season’s most polarising confrontations.
In this TV Central exclusive, Aaron Ryan speaks with the 37-year-old Victorian property investor about leaving the Channel 10 house with no regrets. Matthew also responds to the criticism that followed his arguments over custard and Maltesers, accusations that he gaslit other housemates and Pheobe’s claim that he treated people like puppets.
The conversation gives Matthew the chance to explain the intent behind his outspoken game. He discusses the line between authenticity and confrontation, why he still backs Austin to win and whether Heath or Marshy should follow him out of the house.
Listen To The Podcast
Press play below to hear the full TV Central: One on One podcast with Matthew Karlsson.
Acast
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
The full episode is available now via Acast, Spotify and Apple Podcasts.
What Is Discussed In The Matthew Karlsson Podcast?
- Why Matthew still says he has no regrets about entering the house
- Whether the “Alpha Chameleon” persona contributed to his eviction
- How much of the criticism he directed at Ryan and Kyrah also applies to him
- Why Custardgate became a wider argument about food rules and double standards
- His response to audience boos and criticism of how he handled the confrontation
- What viewers may have interpreted as gaslighting or treating people like puppets
- Why Matthew believes conflict is unavoidable inside the Big Brother house
- His friendship with Austin and why he believes Austin can win
- Whether Heath or Marshy should be the next housemate evicted
Podcast Chapters
- 00:00 TV Central: One on One introduction
- 02:19 Does Matthew still have no regrets?
- 03:15 The Alpha Chameleon persona and the public vote
- 04:18 Accepting the criticism he directed at other housemates
- 05:52 Custardgate, Maltesers and food-rule double standards
- 08:23 Audience boos and responsibility for the confrontation
- 10:39 Gaslighting, control and Pheobe’s puppet criticism
- 12:42 Why it was not the “Be Nice Olympics”
- 13:55 Why Matthew believes Austin can win
- 14:56 Heath, Marshy and who should leave next
- 15:53 Final thoughts after a polarising Big Brother run
Matthew Karlsson Leaves Big Brother With No Regrets
Matthew’s eviction interview with host Mel Tracina began with a direct question about regret. His answer was no. Speaking with TV Central after leaving the house, he maintains that position while acknowledging he was not perfect.
He argues that the artificial pressure of cameras, communal living and a game built around judgement leaves housemates with one realistic option: show their personality and accept the reaction. For Matthew, the many “gates” and confrontations were evidence that he was willing to challenge opinions rather than disappear into the background.
Read TV Central’s complete recap of Matthew’s Big Brother eviction.
Was The Alpha Chameleon Persona His Downfall?
Matthew entered the house describing his huge personality as a superpower. He also called himself the “Alpha Chameleon” and expected to debate, challenge opinions and encourage the people around him to be authentic.
His farewell message played with that reputation. Matthew referred to the “big, scary, intimidating boy” leaving the house, but he tells Aaron the line was intended to take the mickey rather than admit that intimidation was his strategy.
I probably am an alpha at my core.
Matthew Karlsson, TV Central: One on One
Matthew accepts that his mischievous and unapologetic approach can divide people. However, he believes some housemates were flying under the radar while he was prepared to speak openly.
What Matthew Accepts About The Criticism
In his farewell message, Matthew told Ryan that his personality could overwhelm people and that he sometimes behaved as though he knew best. He also advised Kyrah to listen more and stop speaking over others.
Aaron points out that both observations resemble the criticism Australia directed at Matthew. Matthew says he can see the overlap. He describes the house as a group of large personalities with different opinions, but still believes the group needed people willing to bring unresolved issues into the open.
He concedes that his delivery may sometimes have been too dramatic. At the same time, he maintains that house expectations mean little unless the people enforcing them also follow them.
Custardgate Was About More Than Custard
The food dispute became one of the defining storylines of Matthew’s final week. Ryan, Austin and Marshy had hidden custard, while other housemates were also taking extra food. Matthew says his objection was not that people stole food. He was frustrated that Ryan helped enforce rationing while secretly breaking the same expectations.
Matthew says his attention also extended to Marshy and the wider house. However, Ryan became the main focus because Matthew believed he was enforcing the rules more strongly and did not admit what had happened when the issue arose.
The argument grew beyond custard and Maltesers. Matthew connects it to frustration over house meetings, group behaviour and what he saw as people applying different standards to themselves and others.
Audience Boos And Responsibility For The Confrontation
Some members of the eviction-night audience booed while Matthew tried to explain the custard dispute. Aaron asks what responsibility he accepts for the way he handled the situation.
Matthew says the house magnified emotions and turned minor tensions into major events. He acknowledges that the situation did not unfold as he intended. Still, he believes unresolved tensions were already building and that his instinct was to force them into the open.
He also stresses that he does not view Ryan as an enemy. Matthew describes both men as large, emotional personalities who became caught up in an argument over food.
I think he’s a great guy.
Matthew Karlsson on Ryan, TV Central: One on One
Gaslighting, Puppets And Matthew’s Game
A viewer comment accused Matthew of gaslighting people. Pheobe also said he was treating the housemates like puppets in his game. Matthew rejects the idea that his confrontations were part of a calculated strategy.
He points to his defence of Ebony as an example. Matthew says he supported her when he barely knew her and received no strategic benefit from doing so. His decision came from believing that others misunderstood and treated her unfairly.
If I was playing the game, I’m not very good at it, am I?
Matthew Karlsson, TV Central: One on One
For Matthew, authenticity does not mean avoiding difficult conversations. It means being consistent about the behaviour he will accept from himself and others, even when that approach creates conflict.
Why It Was Not The Be Nice Olympics
Matthew’s farewell ended with a message for the house: stop being so sensitive because it was not the “Be Nice Olympics”. He believes that philosophy explains both his impact on the season and the division around him.
You got to be cruel to be kind.
Matthew Karlsson, TV Central: One on One
He argues that people with different ages, jobs, beliefs and life experiences cannot live under constant observation without disagreements. In his view, small offences were allowed to stew until someone had to burst the bubble. Matthew accepts that he was often that person.
Why Matthew Backs Austin To Win
Matthew used his farewell message to tell Austin that he has the qualities Australia wants in a winner. He tells Aaron that the endorsement reflects both friendship and an assessment of Austin’s game.
I see him as a little brother.
Matthew Karlsson on Austin, TV Central: One on One
Matthew describes Austin as funny, genuine and capable of seeing beyond the surface of a situation. He hopes Austin will continue finding his voice and stand up for what he believes rather than retreating under the radar.
Should Heath Or Marshy Leave Next?
Matthew’s farewell was particularly critical of Heath and Marshy. He described one as too guarded and the other as surface-level, then challenged both to reveal more of themselves.
Asked to choose which man should leave next, Matthew calls it an even race. He says both are good people but believes their future depends on whether they can find their feet, express genuine opinions and show Australia who they are.
Watch Matthew Leave The Big Brother House
Matthew Karlsson In Big Brother Australia 2026
Who Is Still In The Big Brother House?
Matthew’s departure leaves 11 housemates competing in Big Brother Australia 2026. The remaining group includes the 10 surviving launch-night housemates and intruder Evie:
- Anita, 47, Tasmania – a travel advisor, skateboarder and sister of two-time winner Reggie Bird
- Austin, 22, Queensland – a carpenter who works with his father and brother
- Charity, 29, New South Wales – one of 13 siblings, guided by family, faith and fun
- Ebony, 23, Victoria – a confident entrepreneur unafraid of confrontation
- Evie, 29, Queensland – an international model from Coffs Harbour who now lives on the Gold Coast and entered as an intruder
- Heath, 23, Queensland – an engineering student whose social energy hides a strategic mind
- Kyrah, 25, New South Wales – an English and Drama teacher with a loud, quick and unpredictable presence
- Marshy, 24, South Australia – a champion forklift salesman with a gift for the gab
- Matty, 39, Western Australia – a mining commentator who enjoys being underestimated
- Ryan, 27, New South Wales – a garden-centre manager whose secret sibling entered alongside him
- Tahlia, 25, Victoria – a support worker with a dry sense of humour and Ryan’s younger sister
Read TV Central’s original Big Brother 2026 housemate profiles and the story of Evie’s arrival as the season’s intruder.
When Is Big Brother Australia On?
Big Brother Australia continues Monday to Friday at 7.30pm and Sundays at 7pm on Channel 10. Viewers can also catch up and watch the 24-hour live stream through 10.
Hear more from this season’s evicted housemates in TV Central’s podcasts with Harmon Singh, Pam Davidson and Pheobe Joyce.
TV Central: One on One Podcast
Season 2026, Episode 18
With thanks to Tess Fisher and the Paramount Australia publicity team for organising this podcast.
For more podcasts from TV Central, visit the TV Central podcast section.























